• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Marcello's New York Pizza - Authentic Thin Crust Pizza in Medina, OH

Marcello’s New York Pizza in Medina, OH, offers an authentic taste of New York’s iconic thin-crust pizza, delivering bold flavors and top-quality ingredients. From the rich, perfectly balanced tomato sauce to the creamy, genuine cheese, every slice reflects care and tradition. The crust strikes a crisp yet tender bite, echoing classic New York style. Customers praise not only the exceptional pizza but also the warm, friendly service, making each visit welcoming. Despite its modest location inside an antique mall plaza, Marcello’s stands out as a local gem and a must-try for those seeking true, satisfying New York-style pizza.

Marcello's New York Pizza at a glance

  • Address 2777 Medina Rd, Medina, OH 44256, United States
  • Phone +1 330-559-3333
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Marcello's New York Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

John Gatsios
5

Okay, there have been several failed pizza shops in this very location. I didn't expect much. What a surprise to have had such a delicious pizza! It's New York style---thin crust---and it's quite delicious. If you haven't yet tried it, I highly recommend it.

Paul Calta
5

As a native New Yorker, I am always looking for good pizza. The pizza here is the best, it is the same as I grew up with many years ago. The ingredients are top quality, not the cheap sauce and waxy cheese that many places sell nowadays. The people there were so friendly and the service was top notch. I mentioned the cheese to Mr. Rossi and he gave me a sample and told me what kind it was. I enjoyed talking "pizza" with him. It was more like eating lunch at my family's house; without the dysfunction. Great place. I cannot wait to eat there again.

Aaron M
5

Look I’m no Dave Portnoy, and I don’t know how to use his pizza scale. But this place just broke into my TOP TWO best pizza joints in Medina! We had the 18” Large NY Style Pep with HUGE Garlic Knots. My goodness this sauce was amazing, did I mention the Garlic Knots?! WE. WILL. BE. BACK. I also didn’t get the lady at the front desks name, but she was very sweet and kind. 12/10 EDIT WITH SECOND VISIT: Stop what you are doing, and order a pizza from Marcello’s right now. This SAUCE IS THE BEST IN TOWN. Right off the highway this joint is awesome and easy to get to. Couldn’t recommend higher. If you want average pizza, go somewhere else. If you want great pizza, get Marcello’s. Crisp, flavors, colors and smells. It’s everything you could want. This is our second pie from this place and it will only be the first few of many more to come. Also, note that the lady at the counter is extremely kind. 12/10

Jeremy S
5

Marcello's is my new pizza obsession in Medina. I like Courthouse Pizza, but I honestly think Marcello's is much better. I don't claim to be a NY style pizza snob, but I do think it tastes great. As of right now, they have great pizza specials on Wednesday and Thursday. The location isn't great (it's tucked back into the Antique Mall plaza), so I'm trying to get the word out to make sure people know about them. It's strictly a carryout place, and the service has been great both times that I've went to pick up our order. Definitely give this place a try... you'll most likely be back not long after.

Rose Gonzalez
5

If you’re debating on trying this place..just do it! It’s amazing!! I am so glad I tried this place while on a road trip. I haven’t had pizza like this in years. I will be back for sure; even though it’s a 6 hour drive for me!

Location

  • Marcello's New York Pizza
    Marcello's New York Pizza
    2777 Medina Rd, Medina, OH 44256, United States Hotline: +1 330-559-3333

Marcello's New York Pizza, tucked away at 2777 Medina Rd in Medina, Ohio, is a hidden gem that’s quickly capturing the hearts of pizza lovers craving an authentic New York slice. This spot nails the essence of true New York style pizza—thin, crisp crust paired with rich, savory sauce and high-quality cheese that reminds native New Yorkers of the pizzerias back home. The attention to authentic ingredients sets Marcello’s apart, steering clear of the overly processed sauces and waxy cheese common in many places today.

What stands out immediately is the perfect balance of flavors in every bite. The large 18” NY style pepperoni pizza boasts an irresistible sauce that’s both tangy and flavorful, complementing the airy yet sturdy crust—a satisfying contrast that invites you to savor each slice. Paired with their generously sized garlic knots, which are aromatic and soft on the inside with just the right hint of garlic, the meal feels complete and indulgent.

Service here goes beyond just efficiency; it’s warm and genuine. From the friendly conversations with the owner about the cheese varieties to the kindness of the staff at the counter, the experience feels personal, like being welcomed into a family kitchen rather than a carryout joint. Despite its unassuming location beneath the Antique Mall plaza, this pizza shines as a beacon of quality and community spirit.

If you’re in Medina or just passing through, skipping Marcello’s means missing out on a standout New York slice that’s winning over skeptics and seasoned pizza aficionados alike. Whether you’re drawn by the promise of a classic thin crust or the reputation of top-tier ingredients and heartfelt service, Marcello’s New York Pizza delivers an experience worth savoring again and again.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards